dictionary

Briefs filed in yet another challenge to absentee ballots

	LEGAL RESOURCES
Latest Legal News
Law Library
FindLaw Consumer Center Select a topic Bankruptcy Discrimination Divorce Estate Planning Landlord-Tenant Personal Injury Taxes

TALLAHASSEE, Florida (CNN) -- Attorneys for Republican George W. Bush and Florida Secretary of State Katherine Harris Wednesday afternoon filed briefs with the Florida Supreme Court in yet another case challenging the legitimacy of absentee ballots in the Florida presidential election.

In this case, Cynthia McCauley, a voter from Bay County in the Florida panhandle is alleging that numerous "illegal votes" were cast by absentee ballots when the voters could have gone to the polls.

The case was dismissed at the district court level on a motion from Harris and the Bush campaign.

Attorneys for Bush and Harris argued in their respective briefs Wednesday that the circuit court's decision was supported by federal law and should be upheld.

"It cannot be the law that a technical error like the one alleged in this case should be allowed to disenfranchise the thousands that voted via absentee ballots," Bush attorneys said.

McCauley alleges that the trial court "misapprehends the nature and effect of unqualified voters casting absentee ballots" and wrongly dismissed the case.

McCauley also alleges other election violations, among them that third parties returned absentee ballots without legal authorization and that election officials did not verify the identity of people returning absentee ballots as required by law.

But Harris' attorneys argued against that point.

"The alleged improper return of absentee ballots by third parties does not, in and of itself, constitute a basis for invalidating all of the absentee ballots cast in Bay County," wrote the attorneys for Harris.

McCauley alleges that the Florida Republican Party sent out a letter "from the desk of Governor Jeb Bush" bearing the state seal and Bush's signature inviting people to cast absentee ballots from "the comfort of your own home."

The solicitation made no mention of the legal requirements for casting an absentee ballot, McCauley alleges, adding that "the mailing intentionally misled recipients of the mailing by implying that absentee voting is an unconditional legal right encouraged and validated by Governor Jeb Bush, himself."

As a result, said McCauley, voters who could have gone to the polls illegally cast absentee ballots.

On November 7, George W. Bush received 38,637 votes in the Bay County-Panama City area, 8,969 of those absentee ballots.

See related sites about LAW

Note: Pages will open in a new browser window

External sites are not endorsed by CNN Interactive.